Sky and Sugar are both placed on the same team during their debut season and, at first, generally seem to get along well enough. However, as the season progresses, Sugar begins to mess with Sky and her relationship with Dave. She even begins to outright insult Sky, causing her to gain a dislike for Sugar and her weird antics. After the merge, Sky realizes that in order to make it to the finale, she needs to find an ally. She reluctantly is forced to choose Sugar, who is looking for an alliance as well after her previous attempt at forming an alliance with Shawn fails. Throughout the alliance, Sky has to put up with Sugar's stupidity and disgusting habits. Eventually, Sugar betrays Sky in Sky Fall, making Sky break the alliance and escalating their conflict. Sky then grows to dislike Sugar, as her belief in fairness and good sportsmanship in competitions clashes with Sugar's manipulation and rude nature.
Seeing that their team needs some morale boost, Sky gives an inspiring speech to them, and everyone cheers once she is done. While discussing who should take which part of the obstacle course, Sugar objects to Dave's plan of putting Sky at the final leg, wanting to put Leonard in her place instead, since she believes that Leonard's "magic" will definitely help them.
Sugar is annoyed by how long Sky takes to drink the jug of mineral water, and claims she could drink a bottle of maple syrup faster than her.
Sugar notices Sky in a depressed state and offers to talk to her about it. The latter tells her that she believes that there might be something going on between Ella and Dave, after seeing Ella putting her hands on Dave's shoulders in the previous episode. Sugar reassures her that she is just imagining things, which makes Sky feel a little better. However, Sugar explains that Dave has been flirting with every girl in the competition, including her, which makes Sky worried again. In the confessional, Sugar reveals that she lied as preparation for the upcoming merge.flirting with each other. She frowns in annoyance and believes that sooner or later the two of them will form an alliance. She explains to Shawn that they have to stop them from bonding any further by forming an alliance of their own; however, Shawn angrily rejects her offer in the confessional. When Sky has some berry juice on her cheeks, Dave attempts to wipe it off, but Sugar quickly pushes Dave aside and then starts wiping Sky's cheek after licking her hand. Due to this, it leaves both Sky and Dave in disgust, with the former losing her appetite. Throughout the episode, Sugar prevents Sky and Dave from sharing any form of a kiss or otherwise tender moment. The first time is after the contestants fall into the ravine, when Sugar vomits on Dave. Later, after the cave-in, Sky and Dave are about to kiss again, but Sugar stops them from doing so by burping loudly and waking up a swarm of bats. At the gem filled cave, when Bling Bear suddenly appears, Sky believes that Sugar must have eaten one of the crystals, which alerts the bear, not knowing the true culprit is Shawn.
Seeing how depressed Dave is as a result of being rejected by Sky, Sugar manages to convince Dave into helping her find Sky during the challenge so that she cannot win the million dollars. Seeing this as a chance for revenge, Dave complies and leads Sugar to the place where he last saw Sky. Sky is still there, and upon seeing her, Sugar immediately tackles her, eliminating her from the challenge.
After Chris leaves the island, Sky suggests to the others that they should split up in groups to find the control center before the island explodes. However, by the time she finishes her sentence, Jasmine, Shawn, Max, and Scarlett have already partnered up with each other, leaving only Sugar with Sky, much to her disappointment. While finding a way into the secret base, Sugar suggests that they should stick with each other, as they are the only "normal contestants" left. Sky sarcastically agrees. However, Sugar accidentally insults Sky by mentioning that she is not acting like a girl much, which greatly frustrates Sky. Eventually, the two of them find a way into the base after the tree they are on retracts back inside. While running away from a mechanical cat, Sky compliments Sugar while using the confessional, saying that, despite Sugar's many flaws, she admires her ability to stay positive even in the most dire situations.
Sky decides to align with Sugar because Jasmine and Shawn's relationship would make it hard to make it to the finals alone. Sky stresses to Sugar that she will not tolerate any cheating, but the latter clearly plans to play dirty nonetheless. Throughout the episode, Sky often has to make up for Sugar's shortcomings, such as carrying her up the mountain. When escaping the bear cave, Sky is disgusted by Sugar's farting tactic and is confused by Sugar's dream to put makeup on animals. Near the finish line, Sugar betrays Sky when Sky attempts to push her forward, stepping aside and causing her to fall off the cliff. However, Sky lands on one of the robot crocodiles and flies to the top, securing a place in the final three. In the confessional, Sky declares that her alliance with Sugar is over.
When Chris mentions how the previously-eliminated contestants will be selected as Sky and Shawn's helpers, they cringe in disgust when the monitor stops on the picture of Sugar posing.
- Both are the highest-ranking female members of their respective teams and the highest-ranking females of Total Drama: Pahkitew Island.
|Interactions with||Everyone | Dave | Shawn | Sugar|
|Interactions with||Everyone | Ella | Sky|