Lindsay's big heart and childlike nature made her one of the most well-liked competitors on the show. Although the other contestants are frequently annoyed by her severe lack of intelligence, Lindsay has been shown to only have pure intentions. A major running gag on the show involves her having problems remembering the name of the others, even if that person is her boyfriend. At times, such as in Dial M for Merger and Get a Clue, she goes beyond the expectation of her peers and demonstrates that she has the ability to solve problems, and likes to be called "Her Hotness" as she does so. She shows herself to be an underdog, and hates to be underestimated by her peers, and does her best to defeat them and prove herself. Unfortunately for Lindsay, due to her naive nature, she is often fooled by false-friendships and easily manipulated by the show's antagonists.
Lindsay is the fifth camper to make her debut by arriving on the island on Total Drama Island in Not So Happy Campers - Part 1. She immediately catches the attention of the boys with her beauty, and Chris calls her "not too shabby". She also immediately puts her ditzy nature on full display, forgetting who Chris is, saying he looks familiar. Chris reminds her of who he is, and pointing out that he is the show's host. Then, Lindsay remembers him. Later, Lindsay asks for a cabin with a lake view, because she is the prettiest. Chris says, that while it's true, that is not how it works. Then, Lindsay is later placed on the Screaming Gophers. When Chris explains the confessional to the campers, Lindsay makes her first confessional. She is confused about where the "camera guy" is, accidentally showing her backside to the camera. Later, Lindsay asks Chris if there are any outlets, so that she can plug in her flat iron. When Chris says that she can find some in the communal bathrooms, Lindsay says that she's not "catholic". Chris corrects Lindsay, saying that it is a communal bathroom, not a communion bathroom. Gwen adds to this, saying "it means we shower together. Idiot." This makes Lindsay very upset. Later, everyone hears a shriek from inside the Gophers cabin.
It turns out to be Lindsay, who is standing on a stool and shrieking at a cockroach, mortified. Several campers try unsuccessfully to crush it, until Duncan slices it in half with an ax. Tyler then impresses Lindsay by telling her that if she ever sees another roach like that, then he should tell her, because he could do that too. This makes Lindsay smile at Tyler, signifying the beginning of their relationship. Lindsay is immediately scared of the daunting first challenge in Not So Happy Campers - Part 2. When Heather refuses to participate in the challenge, Lindsay says "if she's not doing it, then I'm not doing it", and the two smile at each other. After Leshawna throws Heather off the cliff and then jumps herself, Lindsay gets ready to dive. She says "I thought this was gonna be a talent contest!", and jumps. When the Screaming Gophers wheel their crates back to the cabins, Lindsay works together with Noah. Later, Heather apologizes to Leshawna about how she acted earlier, and confides in Lindsay that her apology was not sincere at all. When Lindsay asks why she faked being nice to Leshawna, Heather reminds her of the old adage "keep your friends close and your enemies closer". Lindsay asks if Heather considers her a friend, and Heather assures her that she is, "for now".
When the Killer Bass plan to vote off Courtney, Courtney shifts attention to Tyler instead, and Lindsay blatantly objects to this, despite the two being on opposing teams. Lindsay quickly covers up the awkward moment with the excuse that there is no salt on the table. In The Big Sleep, Lindsay becomes part of the first alliance in Total Drama history. Heather decides to choose Lindsay, due to her being dumb, and Beth, due to her being a wannabe follower. Lindsay becomes excited to be part of an alliance and, according to Heather's promise, reaching the final three. Lindsay also thinks Tyler would be a good candidate for the alliance, but only because she has a crush on him. Heather tells Lindsay that she cannot "inter-team" date, since it is against the alliance rules. In the confessional, Lindsay says that Heather told her that she couldn't date Tyler, but Heather never said that Lindsay couldn't "like" him. When Heather steals Eva's MP3 player, Lindsay predicts that Eva is going to get "like, really mad", which Heather says she is counting on. Lindsay falls asleep soon after Heather says they should discuss strategy.
In Dodgebrawl, Heather gives Beth and Lindsay a review of the alliance rules, and explains that Heather is allowed to use anything belonging to Lindsay and Beth, but her stuff is strictly off-limits. Lindsay tries to object this, but she keeps quiet when Heather threatens to throw her out of the alliance. Heather asks Lindsay and Beth if they "want to have some fun", then proceeds to mock the Killer Bass for losing two challenges in a row. During the challenge, Katie knocks Lindsay out of the first round. Tyler flirts with Lindsay, which Heather sees and angrily throws a dodgeball at Tyler, hitting him in the groin. In a later round, when Tyler tries to prove that he does have real skills in dodgeball, he does manage to hit someone, and that someone, of all people, is Lindsay. Tyler cries out as he rushes to her and picks her up. Due to Lindsay's general clueless nature, she had gotten herself hit in the face with dodgeballs numerous times, making her face a bruised mess. Tyler assures her that she doesn't look that bad, and despite it being against the alliance rules, Lindsay agrees to go on a walk with him. Trent softly tosses a ball at Tyler to eliminate him from the game, prompting Tyler and Lindsay to leave the court. Later, Heather notices that Lindsay is still missing, so she goes off to find her. Lindsay is found cuddling with Tyler under the boat deck, as he whispers something to her. Furious at Lindsay for breaking alliance rules, Heather throws a canoe on Tyler then drags Lindsay back to the court. In the Screaming Gophers' first Campfire Ceremony, Lindsay ends up in the bottom two with Noah. Lindsay looks concerned, but is happy for Izzy receives her marshmallow. In the end, Lindsay receives the final marshmallow.
In Not Quite Famous, Lindsay becomes distressed, and complains to Gwen that she has ran out of fake skin tanner in the Gopher girls' cabin. Gwen, who had just woken up, expresses great disinterest in the matter. However, Lindsay is completely oblivious to her sarcasm, commenting on how tanning in the sun can cause wrinkles, and how Gwen can most likely relate. When Chris calls the campers to the amphitheater, while they wait for him, Lindsay asks if they're going to be watching a musical, stating that she loves musicals, "especially the kind with singing and dancing". Lindsay blows a kiss to Tyler. He catches it and winks at her. She waves at him and then looks at Heather, who has been glaring at her. As Heather turns her head sharply in the other direction, Lindsay gets hit by Heather's ponytail and gets a strand of hair in her mouth. When Chris tells the campers to choose talents for the challenge, Heather officially declares herself, Lindsay, and Beth to be the judges for her team's auditions. Heather performs ballet and is quickly accepted to compete by Lindsay and Beth. Heather tells everyone to take five and then quickly pulls Lindsay aside, asking her if she can keep a secret. Lindsay then tells her a story about her older sister Paula getting diarrhea during a date, and how she had to bring her toilet paper since the bathroom was out, and how she never told a soul. She then remembers that she's on national television, looks at the screen, and apologizes to her sister.
Heather shoves a walkie-talkie into her hand and tells her to follow Gwen and report back. Later, as Lindsay is following Gwen, she becomes very bored. She mocks Heather's words of the issue being "serious", calling it "seriously boring". She then sees Tyler, who is still tied up in his yo-yo string, through her binoculars and is happy she found something "not boring", shifting her view to Tyler's rear. The next scene with Lindsay switches to Lindsay and Tyler making out in the bathroom while Heather yells through the walkie-talkie asking if Lindsay had found anything. Grabbing the walkie-talkie, Lindsay hurriedly replies "On my way back, under." When she returns, Heather tells Lindsay that they need to find Gwen's diary. Lindsay stands guard outside the cabin, and starts to braid her own hair, waiting for Gwen. When Gwen returns, Lindsay tries to stop her with her "martial arts". However, Gwen intimidates her into letting her pass, and succeeds. When Bridgette falls into Tyler's arms after her failed performance, Lindsay is outraged and yells at her to "puke on her own boyfriend", but is quickly silenced by Heather. In order to vote off Justin, Heather uses her alliance with Lindsay and Beth to contribute. Lindsay plays a more minor role in The Sucky Outdoors. Lindsay is disgusted and scared by Izzy's story about a bear that appeared at her house one day. Later, when a "bear" appears at the Gophers' campsite, Lindsay fears that the bear already ate Izzy, which Heather thinks that this is good as she thinks it would ensure that the bear is no longer hungry.
In Phobia Factor, Lindsay says that her fear is walking through a minefield in high heels. As Sadie is holding on to the plank of wood, she mentions that she is afraid of bad haircuts. Lindsay agrees and changes her mind, stating that this fear is far scarier. During breakfast the next day, Lindsay asks how they could possibly know what their fears are, and Gwen tries, in vain, to explain the nature of a "reality show" to the ditzy blonde. Lindsay then accuses the reality show hosts of "eavesdropping" on them. Lindsay and Sadie, having revealed their worst fear being bad haircuts, are brought to the main lodge, while Chris brings two wigs for them to wear. Owen snatches one and tries it on, doing a little ballet dance before tripping and falling over. Chris takes the wig back and plants them on the girls' heads. Later, when Geoff has to conquer his fear of hail, Chris plants a robotic cloud over his head. Lindsay sees the cloud, and thinks it's cute and asks if she could have her own cloud. She begins to chase after the cloud, saying "Here cloudy!" Later, when the day ends, Lindsay goes to the communal bathroom again with Sadie, and they take their wigs off together. They admire each other, with Lindsay saying "I never realized how cute you are!", and Sadie replies "Oh my gosh! You are too!", and the two become friends, helping Sadie feel better after Katie's elimination. After Tyler's elimination, Lindsay is in the confessional, and seems to be okay with Tyler leaving. She says that she'll never forget their time together. Right after that, she accidentally refers to him as "Taylor", but quickly corrects herself, blowing a kiss and saying goodbye to him.
In Up the Creek, Lindsay (wearing a different outfit for the duration of the episode. She is seen wearing blue shorts instead of her orange skirt, and a short red top), along with Beth, insists that Trent come in their canoe, and the three team up for the challenge. As they row to Boney Island, Lindsay lays down on Trent's lap to work on her tan. When Trent begins to sink into quicksand, Lindsay resolves to save him, but only ends up getting stuck herself. Trent calls for help, to which Cody answers by swinging on a vine to grab Trent's hand. He fails to catch Trent, and crashes into a tree instead, but the vine comes back to the quicksand area. Trent is able to grab it and pull himself and Lindsay out of the pit. Extremely grateful, Trent and Lindsay thank Cody for his efforts, and Lindsay asks him where he learned to do that. Cody explains his rope-swinging abilities come from watching several movies. Before leaving Boney Island, Cody uses the quicksand incident as an excuse to switch places with Trent, so that he can ride with Gwen while Cody rides with Lindsay and Beth on the way back. During the Campfire Ceremony, Lindsay ends up in the bottom two yet again, this time with Izzy. Unlike Izzy, who seems to be confident, Lindsay is busy playing with her hair, not paying attention. However, Lindsay is possibly saved due to the RCMP coming for Izzy.
In Paintball Deer Hunter, Heather asks Beth and Lindsay to warm up a shower for her, to which they reluctantly comply. During the challenge, Chris declares Lindsay a hunter for her team. Heather states that she's going to get Beth and Lindsay to protect her during the entire game, and dismisses a suggestion from Gwen that this would be illegal. Once the two arrive at Heather's location, Beth and Lindsay are snarled at by Heather, who orders Lindsay to get her berries. Once Lindsay arrives with the berries, Heather knocks them out of her hands and calls an alliance meeting with Lindsay. She interrupts Beth shooting at a "deer" to tell her she can stay in the alliance if she apologizes for her earlier actions. Lindsay watches Beth and Heather argue when Beth refuses to apologize for her earlier actions. Heather forces Lindsay to give her the paintball gun, and she uses it to hit Beth. When Chris evaluates the performances, Lindsay has a lot of paint on her back. In that night's Campfire Ceremony, Lindsay receives the second marshmallow.
In If You Can't Take The Heat..., after Heather takes charge of the Screaming Gophers, she teaches Lindsay and Gwen how to make a flambé dessert. In the confessional, she describes talking to Lindsay as "talking to an eggplant". When Heather burns her eyebrows while lighting the flambé, Lindsay cannot resist laughing. Later on, Owen, swollen and bloated from the stings, tosses Heather's bag, which she requested earlier, in Heather's direction, but Leshawna intercepts it. She tosses it to Beth, who tosses it to Lindsay. Leshawna says "In the fridge!" to Lindsay, while Heather places her hand for Lindsay to hand her the bag. She doesn't obey Heather and tosses the bag in the walk-in freezer, pretending it was an accident. When Heather runs in after it, Leshawna closes the door behind her and locks her inside. While the campers present their dishes to Chris, Heather is brought up. Leshawna and Chris discuss how Heather was annoying her, and this causes Lindsay to remember that they left Heather locked in the freezer, and runs off to let her out. Before the Campfire Ceremony, The Gophers mull over who they will vote off that night. Heather tells Lindsay that all is forgiven, as long as she votes for whomever Heather tells her to, threatening to cut off all her hair in the middle of the night if she ever steps out of line again. In the confessional, Lindsay laughs over locking Heather in the freezer, saying "that was so cool!"
In Who Can You Trust?, Lindsay is chosen to serve as the cook for her team, against Bridgette. She has to prepare a fugu blowfish, a poisonous Japanese blowfish. She has to prepare it and serve it to Trent. Trent is very nervous upon learning this, and gets Lindsay to confirm she has taken Biology. When the meals are finished, Geoff takes a bite, in which he is fine. Lindsay's dish ends up looking terrible. Knowing she messed it up, Lindsay draws a smile on her blowfish with ketchup to make it look better. Trent takes a bite from Lindsay's dish, punches himself and screams, laughs, then turns blue, falls on the floor and vomits. Trent says "I thought you said you passed Biology", and Lindsay clarifies that she was asked if she took Biology, not if she passed it. In Lindsay's next challenge, a blindfolded Heather prepares to jump to Lindsay, who is on the trapeze, but Lindsay mistimes the point for Heather to jump and Heather winds up in the pond.
In Basic Straining, Lindsay is the first camper to drop out of Chef Hatchet's boot camp challenge. The challenge goes into the night, with Chef telling a story about his time in the army. Lindsay declares she cannot hold the canoe up any longer. Owen tries to stop her, saying "Don't do it, Lindsay!", but Lindsay weakly informs him that she has "no more feeling in her arms". Lindsay heads to the end of the dock, and rings the bell with her head due to exhaustion, eliminating herself and ending the challenge. Chef Hatchet talks to her, and softly says that she has nothing to be ashamed of. However, he takes out his megaphone and shouts at her, saying she should be ashamed for letting her team down. Despite being eliminated, Lindsay also participates in the dancing challenge. She runs along with the rest of her team, cheering for Gwen when she wins the challenge for her team.
In X-Treme Torture, Lindsay shines in the final challenge: the X-Treme Seadoo Water Ski Challenge. Harold skis behind Heather, and Lindsay skis behind Duncan. Lindsay announces that she's ready to compete, while wearing the "very fetch" bikini that she mentioned earlier. Heather feels a sense of despair, worried that Lindsay won't take the challenge seriously, which will ultimately cost them the win and the shower reward. it's Lindsay's turn, and she has no trouble skiing in the mud, grabbing the first flag on a ramp and performing a backflip on the way down. Duncan tries to speed up to get her to lose her balance, but Lindsay keeps going, collecting all the flags, with a determined look on her face. Duncan does not want to cross the finish line and hands victory to the Gophers. He deliberately crashes, sending himself flying into a tree. Lindsay maintains her balance and her momentum carries her to the finish, winning the challenge for the Gophers. She passes Duncan (however, she calls him "Doug") and apologizes, and tells him that she really wanted the shower. Chris pulls up on his ATV, surprised that Lindsay actually won. Duncan gives Lindsay a cold "whatever" after Geoff laments on how he could have used the shower. She jumps off the skis, and gives Leshawna a hug, celebrating winning the challenge for her team.
In Brunch of Disgustingness, throughout the episode, Lindsay builds her friendship with Bridgette when she switches over to the girls' cabin. Heather gives Bridgette Lindsay's bunk, much to Lindsay's protest. Despite the obviously dysfunctional group, Lindsay comments things must be way better than at the guys' cabin, which she is wrong about. Then, Heather draws a line with duct tape, dividing the cabin in half, and Lindsay joins Heather's side due to their alliance. Lindsay asks everyone if they can just "talk this out over low-cal snacks". Before the challenge begins, Duncan winks at the girls, and Lindsay blows a raspberry at him back. During the first part of the "Brunch of Disgustingness" challenge of eating meatballs, while the guys lose all their nerve and even some of the girls are squeamish, Lindsay presses on in hopes of winning a pedicure. When the campers have to eat pizza, Lindsay prepares to give up, refusing to eat it. Bridgette helps Lindsay out, teaching her how to meditate so that Lindsay forgets that the pizza is gross. Later, Lindsay tries some deep meditation that Bridgette shows her to ignore how gross the food is while eating the worms. However, the worms are too much for her, she gags, and forgets where she is. In another challenge, Bridgette gets the idea of funneling the soup directly down the throat, bypassing the tongue and taste senses altogether; she tries it on Lindsay, and it works perfectly. This evens the score up at 2-2. Due to the girls losing, they are forced to stay on Camp Wawanakwa. That night, Gwen and Leshawna lock Heather and Lindsay out of the cabin.
In No Pain, No Game, Lindsay is seen sitting outdoors with Heather before the guys return. A fly lands on Heather's nose, but before she can swat it away, Lindsay smacks her in the face with the magazine that she was reading. Although Lindsay was only trying to swat the fly, Heather starts to yell at her. In the torture challenge, Lindsay's challenge is "Marshmallow Waxing", in which Chef Hatchet applies a melted marshmallow mixture to her face for ten seconds. She has to endure the scorching pain. She succeeds, and is actually happy about how smooth her face has become, thanking "Chip". Chris corrects her, and says that since Lindsay didn't complain during the challenge, she can choose who goes next. Lindsay, with Eva's "encouragement", chooses Bridgette to be the next participant, and her challenge is to stand in a barrel of leeches for ten seconds, because Lindsay quotes Eva, saying she is a "backstabbing lowlife traitor...grr". When Geoff volunteers to do the challenge instead, Lindsay thinks it is very romantic. Lindsay is eliminated from the challenge when she is unwilling to have her hair cut by Chef, using a chainsaw, which Chris calls the "Wawanakwa Hair Salon", making her one of the few campers to do two challenges. In the Campfire Ceremony, Lindsay votes for Eva, because she is scarier than "Gretta", "Lequisha" and Heather combined.
In Search and Do Not Destroy, Lindsay is shown helping Heather complete her challenge by lowering her by rope into Chef Hatchet’s kitchen while Chef is sleeping. Heather manages to slip down without being noticed, and grabs her key. She is then slowly being pulled back up on the rope, when Lindsay sees a bug and lets the rope slip. Heather screams in shock, and ends up dropping her key, which she barely manages to grab again, before she and Lindsay regain control over the rope. Surprisingly, Chef is not awakened by this outburst, and Heather is able to exit the kitchen and keep the key in her possession. After Gwen and Trent finally have their first kiss, the camera zooms out to show Heather and Lindsay looking on angrily. After Heather's confessional, Lindsay is shown in the confessional next, although she has seemingly forgotten that she is in the confessional, and is using the toilet and reading a magazine inside of it. Lindsay is shown after Geoff is shown, looking towards the beehive in which she is supposed to retrieve her key. Izzy then joins her and silently offers to help, walking towards the beehive. She returns several seconds later holding the key, but covered in bees, which then begin to chase Lindsay. Lindsay runs straight to the dock, and jumps off, in order to avoid the mob of bees, while Izzy wishes her luck.
Heather and Izzy are then shown meeting a bee-sting-covered Lindsay on the dock. Heather tells the two girls that they need to break up Trent and Gwen, and she begins telling Lindsay to write a letter to Gwen. Lindsay is shown walking into the Gopher cabin, holding the note to Gwen. She places it on Gwen’s bunk, but then hears Gwen outside the cabin, leading her to hastily hide underneath the bed. While Gwen reads the note, telling her to "meet Trent at the dock of shame for a little surprise," cockroaches build up on Lindsay, leading her to, as soon as Gwen leaves the cabin, run through the door, screaming. Later, Heather and Lindsay are seen meeting behind the communal washrooms, while Geoff cries for help in his search for his key. Heather reminds Lindsay of their plan, telling her to lead Trent to her then watch for Gwen. Lindsay replies that she can be counted on. Heather is then shown impatiently waiting on the dock, claiming that she “knew she couldn’t trust Lindsay". Meanwhile, Gwen is approaching the dock, and Lindsay sees her quickly attempting to give Heather "the signal". Heather does not hear her, and continues to tell Trent that he is "too nice for her to let him get used by Gwen". Lindsay then attempts to notify Heather again, which this time she hears. After the challenge, Lindsay wins an accordion. Lindsay is again shown using the confessional as a restroom, but this time realizes her mistake and quickly covers her face with the magazine, gasping.
Lindsay is the first camper seen in Hide and Be Sneaky, enjoying the Grape-Tastic Pop from Heather's reward in the last episode, which she claims is the only thing she has been craving since she came to the island. Heather remarks on how Leshawna is going to pay for shredding her clothes (which she previously did off-screen.) Lindsay points out that stealing Gwen's boyfriend was "pretty major", but Heather tells Lindsay to shut up and swipes the pop to take a drink. She immediately spits it out, questioning how Lindsay can "drink this sugar water" as she throws it to the ground, causing it to spill. In the confessional, Lindsay states that Heather is her best friend on the island, even though she goes on to say that Heather steals her food, borrows her clothes and calls her names. However, she then states that that is what BFFs (Best Female Friends) are for. Heather then says in the confessional, "Who cares about friends? In this world, there are shepherds and there are sheep, and Lindsay is a major sheep", imitating Lindsay as a sheep by making sheep noises and using her fingers as horns on her head. Back to Lindsay in the stall, she states how she thinks Heather respects her and her "strategical" ideas. Finally, Heather states that she has flip-flops with more brains than Lindsay, but knows that she is useful enough to keep close. Heather goes on to say that when she does not need Lindsay anymore, she'll dump her.
Once Chris gives everyone the signal that the challenge has begun, they all scatter, except for Lindsay, who seems to be confused by the whole matter. Chris makes his way into the cabins, where Lindsay is clearly seen hiding under the covers of one of the beds. Chris asks if she could do any better and she remarks that she fooled him, since the bunk she is hiding in isn't even hers. He then calls for Chef, who kicks the door open, sending Lindsay into a screaming fit as she runs away from the cabins. Leshawna is then seen climbing the dock ladder into the water and using a hollow plant as a breathing straw to hide underwater for a long period of time. Lindsay is shown entering the bathrooms, and hiding in one of the stalls. But Chris knocks on the stall, making it clear that Lindsay is still not hiding well. She runs once she realizes this, causing Chris to say "she's a goner". Heather is shown entering the lodge, Lindsay, who is hiding behind a wooden pole, follows her inside. In Chef's kitchen, Lindsay peeks under the table and greets Heather. Surprised, Heather bumps her head as she gets out from under the table, and she tells Lindsay to find her own hiding place. Lindsay is clearly hurt by Heather's harsh remarks.
As Heather is still telling off Lindsay for trying to hide with her, Chef is seen switching on the light and laughs at the two's surprised faces. Heather quickly sacrifices Lindsay, pushing her into Chef so that she may escape his kitchen. Lindsay screams and he tries to grab her, but she runs out of the kitchen as well. The two scream as they run to the lifeguard chair, and Leshawna can be seen underwater hearing the screams above. From afar Chef pumps up the water-gun, aims, and shoots the two down, making them the first losers of the challenge. For the rest of the challenge, the two follow Chef around in hopes of finding someone to win invincibility. As DJ and Owen fight over who reached the top of the cabins there first, their combined weight causes them to fall through the roof and are soon found by Heather and Lindsay. Though Lindsay suggests they both use one each to get invincibility, Heather tells her to find her own. When Heather tells the girls her plan for who to vote off, she tells them that Lindsay agrees with her, which she blankly does upon being nudged by Heather (even though she is more focused on polishing her nails). Heather goes on to ask Izzy to vote with her and Lindsay, as they'd be like best female friends. Izzy openly accepts, but Leshawna points out that Heather would just dump her after the vote, and even Lindsay states this to be true. Heather jabs Lindsay with her elbow, spilling Lindsay's limited edition nail-polish all over the floor, causing Lindsay to question their friendship for the first time.
Unfortunately for Lindsay, she reaches her downfall in That's Off the Chain! It opens with Heather and Lindsay lounging out on the dock. As a fly hovers around Lindsay and Heather, Lindsay tries to hit it with a flyswatter. When the fly lands on Heather's face, Lindsay accidentally smacks Heather's face, clearly aggravating her. Heather asks for the flyswatter from Lindsay, who later uses it to swat Lindsay across the face repeatedly in retaliation. Then she raises her foot, ordering Lindsay to clip her toenails, which look particularly disgusting. Lindsay suggests to Heather that they should form a girl's alliance, but the suggestion is immediately shot down by Heather's swat to Lindsay's face. As the campers build their bikes, Owen states he's going to make his dream-bike, while Lindsay begins to talk about how every Christmas she had asked for a bike called a "Sunset Sally", but had never received one. Owen and DJ tear up at the fact Santa never got Lindsay her Christmas wish, but Duncan simply scoffs at them, reminding them that this isn't a Christmas wish challenge. Heather mocks the guys in the confessional and states that she does not plan on building her own bike, when someone can do it for her.
As Leshawna comforts Lindsay, Heather pulls Lindsay aside to tell her to dismantle Chef's bike so that she can use the parts from his bike to soup up her bike and gain an advantage in the competition. Though Lindsay questions it and even points out that she needs to build her own bike, Heather tries to convince her she can't save Lindsay unless Heather herself wins, saying "We're BFFs, remember? Would I steer you wrong?". In the confessional, Lindsay then states that maybe she's naïve, but Heather has always been trustworthy to her before, that she knows of. Heather puts Lindsay in the Arts and Crafts Center with a wrench in hand and closes the door, telling other girls that they'll have to wait their turns. Lindsay finds a rag-doll and shows it to Heather saying that it's an ugly doll with pretty hair, just like Heather, and that she plans on using it for her bike. In the confessional, Lindsay explains that she tends to say the wrong things, such as when she told her math teacher that his new hairpiece looked like her dog's butt, which he "totally took it the wrong way". She goes on to explain that this is because her dog has the cutest, curliest little butt, and that it is a compliment. Heather acts humored by Lindsay's comment, but reminds her to finish her bike first so she can protect Lindsay from the vote. Again in the confessional, Lindsay talks about how she got trapped in a three-way calling attack, and that she told one friend about how another friend was cheating on her with her boyfriend "or something". Lindsay goes on to say she "totally got dumped that day", unaware it was completely her doing by saying, "It was so random! I wonder if it had something to do with the call?".
Later, as Chris checks Lindsay's "Sunset Sally", she tells him to ring the bell, but as he does, she goes on to say, "The real bike has sound-effects like this", beginning to neigh like a horse. In the first part of the challenge, Lindsay tells her she got Heather's bike, giving Heather a new advantage. Heather explains to Lindsay, "If you cross the finish line on my bike, then I get to ride for invincibility". Heather goes on to tell Lindsay to press the red button on her bike if it looks like she's losing. Lindsay does well in the challenge, easily passing everyone and making it to the final race for invincibility. Owen and Lindsay chat before the race. Heather then explains her plans to Lindsay, stating they need to stick together so that one of them wins the race. She then tells Lindsay to go first to clear up a path through the mines, go through the oil slick so she knows how to get through it and to keep the piranhas busy while she speeds through. Though Lindsay states that this will cause Heather to win and not herself, Heather simply acts as though that's the right thing to do, fooling Lindsay just as she planned. Lindsay is blasted right past the land-mines and easily drives through the oil slick while performing a wheelie. At the same time, she clears a path for Heather with her bike's broom of a horsetail. When Lindsay reaches the pool of piranhas, she comes to a halt on the far edge of the pool, avoiding the piranhas just in time. Heather, just behind her, presses the red button on her bike, flying past the final obstacle along with Lindsay. Heather passes the finish line giving herself the invincibility while Lindsay rushes over to celebrate their safety.
Chris suddenly interrupts stating that Lindsay is actually the last one to cross the line, meaning she is eliminated. Heather then states she can't use her invincibility to save Lindsay as it would be too risky. As Heather begins to walk away, Lindsay grabs her by the arm stating, "But I won, I even built your bike". But Heather laughs this off and acts like she doesn't know what Lindsay is talking about, suggesting Lindsay should just leave with her dignity intact. Lindsay then points out they were supposed to go to the final three together, but Heather clearly doesn't care. Lindsay then asks if she's even sad, stating that they're BFFs. Heather replies that it was only for the contest and that they weren't going to be best friends for life. Lindsay is shocked, even mentioning how they pinky-swore but Heather then further shocks Lindsay, "Uhm, truth? Not really, no. What? We're not here to make friends, we're here to become celebrities, remember?". Furious, Lindsay lashes out at Heather, swearing, flipping-off and cussing her out, which most of them are censored. Lindsay goes on to say that she stood up for Heather because she thought they were BFFs, but realizes that everyone is right and continues to repeat everything she just said to Heather which continues to be bleeped out. Her curse initially makes everyone stands stunned and shocked at Lindsay's comments.
But they all begin mocking Heather and cheering Lindsay later on. Suddenly, Izzy and Leshawna race by Gwen with Leshawna screaming to get off as the two plummet into the lake. Afterward, in the confessional, Lindsay says she doesn't know what came over her, but quickly unleashes a third censored tirade. As Lindsay gets ready to leave, she says goodbye to Gwen and Leshawna (calling them Greta and Lequisha because she keeps forgetting their names) and thanks them for all their support. Leshawna tells Lindsay that they would've kept her on if they could have. Lindsay thanks her again and asks Leshawna to kick Heather's butt for her, to which Leshawna happily agrees. She bids the others goodbye and tells Owen she'll miss him the most. Owen breaks down in tears and hugs her saying he'll miss her too. Finally, Lindsay tells Heather she hopes she gets everything her karma owes her. She boards the boat and the other campers (with the exception of Heather) all wave goodbye as the boat speeds away into the sunset, ending the episode.
Lindsay returns as part of the Peanut Gallery of the eliminated campers in The Very Last Episode, Really!, and supports Gwen. Before she arrives with everyone else, Gwen calls Lindsay "dim-witted" in her confessional. When Owen promises a party if he wins, Lindsay remains on Gwen's side, until Owen says that the party will be on a yacht. When Owen and Gwen both come close to the finish line, Lindsay worries that Owen is losing and thus, the yacht party won't happen. Izzy comes up with a plan, and the two work together to help Owen win. Izzy arrives with a plate of brownies and has Lindsay turn the fan on to blow the scent towards Owen. Initially, Lindsay has the fan backward and blows the other way, knocking off Heather's wig. Realizing her mistake, she turns the fan around. In Gwen's ending, Lindsay cries due to losing the chance to go to a yacht party, tightly hugging Beth. In Owen's ending, Lindsay turns the fan in the correct direction and Owen smells the brownies. With a renewed sense of energy, Owen barrels through Gwen and across the finish line first, crashing into Izzy and winning the challenge.
In Total Drama, Drama, Drama, Drama Island, Lindsay considers Beth as her best friend, due to their hatred for Heather. They pair up with Ezekiel in the search for the case. At one point, Lindsay and Beth blindly walk right pass the case as they were too busy talking, ignoring Ezekiel's attempt to alert them. They eventually found the case by the river but it is stolen by Courtney and Duncan. Near the end of the episode, they find the case yet again, this time near the washroom. Justin soon appears and tricks Lindsay into giving him the case. Ultimately, Lindsay and Beth manage to reach the docks in time and both are among those who qualify for Total Drama Action.
Introduced in Monster Cash, Lindsay is impressed with the dressing room confessional and takes pictures of the film lot, excited about the theme of the season. When Lindsay sees that Beth has had her braces removed, she comments on how Beth is beginning to look the part of her new BFF (Best French Friend, according to her). She becomes closer to her friend (and soon to be BFF) Beth and the two are often seen doing many things together. She still hates Heather for betraying her last season. At the end of the episode, she decides to share a bunk with Beth. She is put on the Killer Grips, after being Trent's first choice for being beautiful. As a running gag throughout the season, Lindsay believes that her boyfriend, Tyler, is still present in the competition, often getting his name wrong in the process which causes the cast to be more annoyed with her stupidity, but she eventually gets the message that he is not in the season.
In Alien Resurr-eggtion, Lindsay is disgusted by Izzy putting ketchup on her pancakes during breakfast. During the challenge, she goes to the confessional with Beth and talks about Heather. Lindsay groups with Justin, Beth and Leshawna during the challenge. She is eliminated early in the challenge with the rest of her group. When Geoff and Bridgette are eliminated, Lindsay (and Beth) thinks that their romance is sweet. In Riot On Set, Lindsay is the first castmate picked for the Killer Grips by Trent, who refers to her as "the beautiful Lindsay," which Lindsay is happy to hear. During the team picking, Lindsay asks Trent to pick Tyler for the team, after which she is told that Tyler isn't in the game anymore. As the cast mates participate in the challenge and carry the film equipment up, Lindsay immediately helps up Trent when he falls. Later, she helps Izzy with her makeup, taking a long time which Izzy complains about to her. At the Killer Grips's first Gilded Chris Ceremony, Lindsay is in the bottom three with Justin and Izzy, and is declared safe.
Early in the season, she grows a strong attraction to Justin, which gets to the point that she argues with Beth over him in Beach Blanket Bogus, with their friendship temporarily strained, but repaired at the end. Unbeknownst to them, Lindsay and Beth end up being in the exact same position they were in last season. This time, they are now being manipulated by Justin to do his bidding and removing anyone who is a threat to him. During the challenge, Lindsay tries to put on suntan lotion, which freezes and hits Harold. During the challenge, she is knocked off the surfboard by a heavy stage fan. Later, Chris throws her at Duncan when he competes. During the second part of the challenge, Lindsay suggests using things from her handbag (including her magazines) to create the team's sandcastle, helping her team win the second part.
In 3:10 to Crazytown, Lindsay takes on the first challenge with Beth, and they help each other conquer it. During the second part of the challenge, Lindsay ropes Trent, and he gets annoyed, reminding her that they're on the same team. After the Killer Grips lose, Lindsay receives the first Gilded Chris Award at the Gilded Chris Ceremony. After Trent is eliminated and as her team's losing streak continues, Lindsay starts to take a leadership position, gaining confidence and independence rather than being a pawn of another contestant. In the episode following Trent's elimination, The Chefshank Redemption, Justin frequently reminds Lindsay that Gwen will throw the challenge for the Screaming Gaffers, in turn manipulating Lindsay into doing all the work for the team. Lindsay is chosen to compete in the first challenge: eating prison food, prepared by the opposing team. She begins to eat the food which has DJ's spices in it, and immediately loves it. However, she fails due to seeing Gwen puke up Beth's retainer, and then seeing Beth put her puke-covered retainer back in her mouth. During the second part of the challenge, Lindsay is reluctant to push the cart for her team, but finally agrees to it after Justin compliments her, calling her legs "foxy." During the race, Lindsay complains about how heavy "Omar" and Justin are. However, in the end, Lindsay wins the race for her team, and consequently the day's challenge, earning their team the win.
In One Flu Over the Cuckoos, Lindsay complains that her "brain is full" before the challenge begins. She performs well in the challenge, and later falls victim to explosive diarrhea due to "Mortatistical Crumples Disease," which turns out to be due to the laxatives in the pizza from the previous night. In The Sand Witch Project, she is bothered by Heather, who calls her and Beth "spineless followers", and shows an x-ray of her spine in the confessional, misunderstanding Heather's words. However, she later tries to prove that she can be a good leader. She is shown to be able to plan out good strategies, such as selecting Beth as their team's killer since she cannot scream, shocking her team with her new and assertive attitude. During the first part of the challenge, the Scream-Off, Lindsay sits in the outhouse and discusses her "accidental tinkle" on camera last season, saying she will not repeat it. Lindsay performs well in the challenge, screaming loudly when Beth enters the outhouse to scare her. However, this is due to her accidentally peeing on camera again. Despite this, she still scores a point for her team. During the second part of the challenge when the Gaffers try to scare the Grips, Lindsay takes charge of her team and nearly wins. In the end, her team still loses and she is in the bottom two with Justin, however, it is not revealed who is eliminated due to DJ quitting.
In Masters of Disasters, Lindsay fights with Justin over who gets to use the code during the final challenge, frustrating Izzy. Despite her incompetence in the Disaster movie challenge, Lindsay doesn't give up and takes on the leadership role again in the following episode, under the title "Admiral Lindsay, Her Hotness." During the first part of the challenge, when they have to sky-dive out of a plane, Lindsay shows that she is now immune to Justin's charms, frustrating him and making Lindsay tired of Justin's lazy and entitled attitude. During the second challenge, Lindsay tells Justin to drop the "crazy act" and help the team with the challenge. In the third and final challenge, Lindsay directs her team as "Admiral Lindsay, Her Hotness," with Beth's help. She and Beth devise a plan to win, and Lindsay stays behind to rest while the rest of her team attack. When the Killer Grips lose again and end up at another Gilded Chris Ceremony, Lindsay admits that she performed poorly in the challenge, and states that if she is eliminated, she will blame no one except herself (and Beth). When Izzy is eliminated, Justin reveals in the confessional that he used a new technique to win over Lindsay and have her vote for Izzy instead of him.
Lindsay continues to dominate her team in Ocean's Eight - Or Nine, as she excitedly tries to crack open the safe. However, she has no clue about what the combination could be, and so she tries her Junior High locker combination, saying that it never changed through all the years she was there. When the combination fails, she complains about the lack of "school spirit." As Justin speaks to Chris, Lindsay can be seen jumping on the safe-cracker to try and open it, failing. Later, Lindsay and Beth fail to participate in building the go-karts due to being chased by Owen, who thinks they were food. During the Gilded Chris Ceremony, Lindsay receives the first Gilded Chris Award. When Chris angrily repeats that Courtney is immune, Lindsay confesses that her finger would only touch the Courtney button on the voting device. She is upset to see Owen eliminated, and, along with Justin and Beth, asks for a speech from him. Owen then compliments Lindsay on her "soda-poppy" beauty, which Lindsay is confused by.
The moment Courtney returns, Lindsay immediately clashes with her, as Courtney grows annoyed by Lindsay's stupidity and Lindsay grows angry as Courtney asserts herself as their team captain and the latter's unfair advantages. In One Million Bucks, B.C., Lindsay complains about Courtney's arrival spelling disaster for her new leadership, forming a conflict with her very early. During the first challenge, Courtney berates Lindsay by commenting on her incompetence in challenges. In the confessional, Lindsay displays anger toward Courtney. Then, Lindsay gains the upper hand in this rivalry in this episode by successfully and effortlessly winning the fire-creating challenge for her team, when Courtney could not. However, Lindsay is less competent in the second challenge, when she loses to Leshawna quickly. Despite her loss, Lindsay seems happy due to being covered in tar, which she and Justin find out is good for their skin. In Million Dollar Babies, Lindsay believes that the day's challenge is, in fact, a gardening challenge at first, and claims that no one can "touch her tomatoes." Lindsay is sorted into the bottom tier through the seeding, and has to fight Harold in a boxing match. Lindsay easily defeats Harold, however Chris declares Harold the winner due to his superior slow-motion skills, and Lindsay having points docked due to eating her marshmallow boxing glove.
In Dial M for Merger, Lindsay is the first castmate to fall into the underground pit. Throughout the first part of the episode, Lindsay continues to act stupidly. When Chris announces the merge, Lindsay is upset to not be on the same team as Beth anymore. In the first part of the challenge, Lindsay loses to Courtney, getting stuck in between the lasers with Beth. However, Lindsay's performance changes in the second part of the challenge, where she succeeds in figuring out which wire to cut, cutting the blue wire due to it being the most "fashion forward." After the challenge, Lindsay talks about tomatoes being good for the skin because of the nutrients it contains, and enjoys the tomato bath (which was set to remove the stink from the stink bombs). In the end, Lindsay wins the reward with Courtney in which they both get to travel to a cheese factory together which ends up being extremely awkward, ending with Courtney throwing herself out of the Lame-o-sine.
In Super Hero-ld, Lindsay brings back some cheese from her reward. While constructing her superhero costume, she complains about Courtney's power trip. She is later unaffected by Pythonicus's efforts to sabotage her. When the cast mates model their costumes, Lindsay wins the challenge as Wonder Woman, stating that the name is based off of her "wondering" things a lot, and talks about her invisible jet. Chris gives Lindsay the win, and docks Courtney's points for stepping on Lindsay's invisible jet. Lindsay then offers everyone a ride on it. However, Lindsay's performance in the second part of the challenge is not as impressive, despite ten seconds being docked from her overall time. After the challenge, Lindsay wants to vote off Courtney despite her getting invincibility. In the Gilded Chris Ceremony, Lindsay is the fifth person to receive a Gilded Chris Award, ending up in the bottom three but is safe.
In The Princess Pride, Lindsay creates a "friendship burrito" with Beth for Duncan's contest, and once again shows herself to be immune to Justin's charms. When Chris arrives to pick a princess between the two previous winners, Lindsay fails to become the "princess" due to her feet being too big and her foot not fitting in the glass boot. This causes the others to tease her. During the first part of the challenge, Lindsay breaks the suspension bridge and falls, losing the challenge. Lindsay spectates the rest of the challenge with Chris. Lindsay is shown to be jealous of Courtney being the princess and gets back at her by using the Princess Courtney Dolls as voodoo dolls. During the Gilded Chris Ceremony, Lindsay happily plays with the dolls when they are changed to Princess Beth dolls and is the third castmate to receive a Gilded Chris Award.
In Get a Clue, Lindsay is once again underestimated by everyone when she tries to decipher Chris's message to find him, suggesting that he is buried alive, but her idea gets ignored in favor of Courtney's. In the confessional, Lindsay complains about no one listening to her due to Courtney's arrival. Back at the trailers, Lindsay and Courtney continue to argue. Courtney makes it up to Lindsay by giving her a spa treatment, which is actually just a way to trick Lindsay into getting her DNA sample. Later, Lindsay tries to get Courtney's DNA when she comes out of the shower, but fails. Right afterwards, Beth tricks Lindsay into getting her DNA by asking Lindsay to reach into her spaghetti for her retainer. When they arrive at the train station, Lindsay is upset when she cannot give any DNA samples to Chris. When the challenge begins, Lindsay panics when she sees Chris's "dead body." She begins to tell everyone a story about her cheerleading squad, about a girl who passed out, however the story doesn't solve their problem. Lindsay decides to draw Chris's outline with some lipstick, wondering why that is done.
After stating that she doesn't want to be murdered like Harold, Lindsay begins to dust the train for fingerprints. Lindsay then accuses Duncan of being the murder, stating that it's because Duncan is Courtney's love interest, and has Harold and Beth handcuff him. Harold and Beth then listen to Lindsay's guidance, much to Courtney's chagrin. This leads to the two fighting again. Despite having support from no one, not even Beth, Lindsay manages to solve the crime after finding a napkin with orange fingerprints on it. Through this logic, Lindsay figures out that Courtney is the real murderer, and orders Harold and Beth to "cuff" her. Chris then enters the cart, and declares "Detective Lindsay" the winner, after which Lindsay states that she wants to be called "Detective Lindsay, Her Hotness." Lindsay receives a reward: a night at the movies with a friend. Lindsay decides to take Duncan as an apology for accusing him of the crime, however ends up in an awkward situation with nothing to talk to him about. In the confessional, Lindsay discusses her "strategistical, logical move, because it messed with Courtney's head."
Courtney and Lindsay continue to get on each other nerves in Rock n' Rule. At the start of the episode, Lindsay sings a song off-key which drives Courtney crazy and leads to her scolding Lindsay. When Chris announces that someone is returning to the competition, Lindsay hopes it is Tyler but is happy when it turns out to be her good friend Owen. Lindsay does badly at the first challenge as she gets electrocuted very early on. Despite that, she performs exceptionally well in the second challenge, taking time to pose for the fake paparazzi which everyone else avoided and comes in first place. She is rewarded with an additional 20 seconds in the third part of the challenge to destroy things, but it is of no help as by that stage, Courtney had already destroyed everything, thereby winning immunity for the third time. Lindsay and Beth both plan on getting Duncan eliminated again and manages to get Harold to join in. However, during the elimination ceremony, Lindsay clumsily votes for herself after being distracted by Beth, leading to her elimination. After sharing a hug with Beth, Lindsay bids everyone goodbye before entering the Lame-o-sine.
In the finale, Lindsay is an avid supporter of Beth, and wishes that she win. When it is her turn to ask a finalist a question, she states that she is voting for Beth because she is her BFF and Beth states that she will take her on a cruise if she wins. Chris makes Lindsay rephrase her statement into a question, which Beth and Duncan both get right, leaving her confused on who to vote for. During voting, Lindsay sneezes on her ballot and her vote does not count. After the winner is declared, she is impressed to see Beth's boyfriend in person.
It is revealed in Celebrity Manhunt's Total Drama Action Reunion Special that after Total Drama Action ended, Lindsay and Beth went on a vacation to Paris but ended up in jail after Lindsay smudged the Mona Lisa. In order to bail them out, Beth's parents have to sell their expensive car, or if Beth is the winner, she uses her prize money instead. She is reunited with the other contestants at the Gemmie Awards and joins them in stopping Chris from starting his new reality show. After one event leads to another, Lindsay is among those who were saved by Chris and qualifies for the next season.
Upon her arrival at the airport in Walk Like An Egyptian - Part 1, Lindsay blows a kiss to the camera when she is introduced. As Chris gives them a tour of the Total Drama Jumbo Jet, Lindsay finds herself in the first class compartment with Alejandro, Bridgette, DJ and Tyler. Alejandro compliments Lindsay by saying that the first class conditions are the type that a lady like Lindsay deserves. This immediately makes Lindsay attracted to Alejandro, who starts blushing at his flirting. Meanwhile, Tyler talks to DJ and says that Lindsay is supposed to like him. DJ says that no one can resist Alejandro, so Tyler tries to impress Lindsay by doing a handspring. He fails, and gets hurt. A concerned Lindsay asks him if he is okay, but forgets his name, as opposed to last season when she mentioned him repeatedly. She calls him "Alejandro", and the real Alejandro reminds her that "Alejandro" is his name. Lindsay compliments him, saying that it is a really nice name. Later, when the contestants sing Come Fly With Us, Lindsay sings it with Alejandro and Bridgette in first class. During the "Pyramid Under Over" challenge, Lindsay goes with Alejandro and Bridgette and climbs the pyramid.
She watches Alejandro climb the pyramid, and calls him the "cutest mountain goat" ever. Tyler chases after her, saying he can be a goat too. When they get to the top, Lindsay rides on Bridgette's shoulders as they surf to the bottom. Alejandro allows the two girls to go to the finish line before him, and Lindsay is placed on the winning team: Team Victory, with DJ, Harold, Leshawna, Bridgette and Ezekiel. In Walk Like An Egyptian - Part 2, Lindsay does less than she did in the previous challenge. She leaves most of the work to Harold, upon his request. As her team navigates through the desert and they see a cactus that they already saw, Lindsay waves to the cactus. When the team's stick breaks, Lindsay reveals that she does not know what a divining rod is, asking Harold to explain. During Rowin' Time, she informs Harold that the crocodiles attacking their boat are getting "killy". After her team loses, Chris is unsure that Lindsay knows how to use the voting devices. Lindsay assures him that she does, but ends up stamping all the passports for fun.
In Super Happy Crazy Fun Time Japan, Lindsay appears to have built a friendship with Bridgette, as both giggle when Harold says he could have also used a crate to block the hole in the plane, but chooses to leave the ladies wanting more. When Chris calls the contestants to the common area to discuss the challenge, Harold asks if the challenge is for elimination or reward. When Chris refuses to tell them, Tyler theorizes to Lindsay that he thinks it is probably going to be a reward challenge, since the last two challenges were eliminations. This excites Lindsay, and she expresses her wish of the prize being candy, or shoes, or even shoes made of candy. When Alejandro starts to pet Tsing-Tsing the panda and ask him if he wants a cookie, Lindsay, along with Bridgette, Izzy and Leshawna, think it is adorable. When Chris tells them that the second part of the challenge is to create a commercial for Chef Hatchet's Total Drama Yum Yum Happy Go Time Candy Fish Tails, Lindsay tells everyone a story about when she went to a Japanese restaurant and had a huge bowl of Pad Thai. Leshawna gets mad and snaps at Lindsay, telling her that Pad Thai is Thai, and not Japanese. Later, when Harold's commercial flops, Leshawna says that they should have gone with Lindsay's idea, and Lindsay says "See? I told you!" At the Barf Bag Ceremony, Lindsay once again messes up the voting. She enters the voting booth, admires the picture of her, saying it is a very good picture, hugs her passport, and leaves. Despite this, she receives the first barf bag.
In Anything Yukon Do, I Can Do Better, when the plane starts to shake and the seat belt lights come on, Lindsay becomes afraid. She crosses her fingers, arms, and legs for luck. When they arrive in the Yukon, Lindsay, along with everyone else is very cold. She, along with Izzy and Leshawna, cuddles Alejandro to stay warm. During the ice flow jumping challenge, Lindsay passes by Tyler, and calls him "Noah". Tyler is not pleased by this, and says "It's T-T-Tyler!", while shivering. Lindsay is the first member of Team Victory that is picked up, since DJ and Leshawna were there from the start. From then on, Lindsay relaxes in her team's sled, gossiping to Leshawna about Harold. Later, when DJ hits a baby seal, Lindsay and Leshawna try to convince him that the seal is okay, using his eyes being frozen shut to their advantage, since DJ wanted to stop and help the animal. This is a lie, as the baby seal had fallen off the cliff. Unfortunately for Lindsay, her team loses yet again, due to the Curse of the Mummified Dog. However, in the Barf Bag Ceremony, Lindsay is the first contestant to receive a barf bag. Afterwards, as Tyler gives his confessional about how he finally made a name for himself in this episode, Lindsay barges in by accident, and apologizes, calling him "Noah" again.
Lindsay grows tired of her team's losing streak in Broadway, Baby!, and takes charge of her team, similar to what she did last season. Lindsay manages to rally Leshawna and DJ's mood and motivate them with a quick speech. Leshawna approves of Lindsay's attitude, while in the confessional, Lindsay admits that she only wants to win because she has brought a whole season's supply of lip gloss, and wants to be able to finish it all. Alejandro then walks into the economy class section, bringing food for the girls in the other teams. Lindsay tries to resist at first, but she notices her favorite type of chocolate, grabs it, and messily eats it. At the drop zone of the Total Drama Jumbo Jet, Chris gathers the remaining thirteen contestants into a small boat. Tyler asks Lindsay if she likes the boat, and Lindsay replies, but gets his name wrong again, this time calling him "Dave". Chris reveals that they are in New York City. Lindsay is ecstatic to be in New York, due to all of the stores and temptation to purchase many things. She says that she is going to buy ten season's worth of lip gloss without even trying. After Chris explains the challenge, Lindsay asks when they will go shopping, and Chris bluntly states that they won't, causing Lindsay to scream in horror.
While navigating the sewers in their boat, Lindsay hears a strange roaring sound, and asks if it was an alligator. DJ assures her that alligators in sewers are nothing more than an urban myth. She later cheers when her team makes it out of the sewers. Before the second part of the challenge begins, and the teams have to choose who pushes the baby carriage, Lindsay says that she wants to be in the baby carriage. She explains that it is because she loves to be called "baby", which causes Noah to tell Tyler to make a "mental note" of it. Lindsay has a major role in What's Not To Love, singing a big part of the song, due to her excitement about being in New York. During the song, when DJ and Leshawna stop dancing, Lindsay asserts her newfound authority and tells them to stop and focus on the challenge. Despite her team having the shortest path, they arrive to the finish line last. When Leshawna questions this, Lindsay says it is because her and DJ's dancing took the longest to recover from. As DJ recovers the apple from Turtle Pond, he tosses it to Lindsay. Due to Lindsay taking charge, her team does not come in last for once, coming in second place, which Chris congratulates them for.
In Slap Slap Revolution, Lindsay continues her running gag of forgetting her boyfriend's name, this time calling him Darrel when they reach the Alps. This makes Tyler even more upset than ever, and he tries to jog Lindsay's memory, saying that they were together in season one. Lindsay says that he must have her confused with someone else, as the only boy Lindsay has ever liked on Total Drama is Tyler, and he is never returning. When Chris arrives and tells the contestants to keep quiet or risk an avalanche, Lindsay misunderstands him, believing that there is a sale at the Khaki Barn. This causes her to yell in excitement and have her mouth covered by Tyler and Cody. During Eine Kleine, Lindsay sings about something "itching" in her brain, remembering that someone is back in the game, and recalls it to be her "former flame", Tyler. She walks over to Tyler, and hugs him, ecstatic that he returned. This overjoys Tyler, who screams "YES" and causes an avalanche. After the song, Lindsay gushes to DJ and Leshawna about her excitement due to Tyler being back. Leshawna plays along, and acts surprised, telling DJ that sometimes it is easier when you go along with her bubbly nature. During the sausage making challenge, Lindsay is in charge of packing down the meat. She cheers when Leshawna starts beating up Heather, even though it costs their team the win. Lindsay's team loses again, landing them in yet another Barf Bag Ceremony, where Lindsay receives the first barf bag for the third time in a row.
In The Am-AH-Zon Race, Lindsay comforts DJ about his curse, saying that they might just become the best team ever, which makes Chris taunt them. Lindsay is also upset about Leshawna's absence, wishing they had not voted her off. Tyler, while talking to his team, says that being in economy class is not all bad, referring to being with Lindsay. During the challenge, when Lindsay decides to take the left route by playing eenie-meenie, Tyler agrees with her and asks Team Chris Is Really Really Really Really Hot to follow. For once, Lindsay and her team (consisting only of her and DJ) are in the lead, and they reach the zipline first. This allows them to use the T-Bar, and Lindsay rides on DJ's shoulders to the other side. On the walkie-talkies, Lindsay excitedly gushes about how her team is in first place, and greets Tyler, despite not being able to see him. Tyler waves back. When night falls, Chris catches up to Lindsay and DJ and rewards them with a crate of bananas to eat for dinner. Lindsay feasts on them, and falls asleep peacefully. With night fallen, Lindsay wakes up to a pattering sound.
She shines her flashlight on DJ, and he notices that he had been slapping monkeys who wanted their bananas, not bugs. He sighs at the fact that his curse has still not worn away. In the morning, it is shown that DJ has bandaged the wounds, and the two tread lightly. However, when the monkeys attack DJ, Lindsay watches in fright. When they finally reach Machu Picchu, and DJ once again acts upset about his curse, Lindsay points out that this time, the animals attacked him, rather than the other way around. The team continues to keep their lead, and they hunt for the golden statue. When Tyler and Owen think they have found it, Lindsay returns with the actual statue, and wins the challenge for her team. Finally in first class, the two are able to relax for the first time. DJ helps himself to a cookie, and Lindsay begins to ask him a question. DJ already knows it, however, and allows her to bring Tyler into the first-class section with her. Lindsay happily thanks DJ and kisses him on the cheek before running off to get him. In the exclusive clip of the episode, in the cockpit of the Total Drama Jumbo Jet, DJ and Lindsay are shown to be flying the plane as a reward.
In Can't Help Falling in Louvre, Lindsay is one of the first characters seen. She is seen relaxing in first class, enjoying the luxury. She is also excited to see Tyler, now that she finally remembers him, and discusses DJ's new "vegan" lifestyle with him. Lindsay misunderstands DJ, thinking he said he was "Megan". Meanwhile, in the economy class section, Tyler complains about missing Lindsay. When Lindsay finds out that they have arrived in Paris, she says that there is only one person she wants to share it with. She asks where her Tyler is, and Tyler shows up beside her. She looks confused, and says that he looked different in her head. Alejandro comments that everything looks different in her head. Lindsay asks her boyfriend if he always wears a tracksuit, then says that she is going to take him shopping after the challenge is over. During the challenge, Lindsay has to build "The Thinker", and due to DJ running off to the Egypt section to end his curse, Lindsay is left doing the entire challenge by herself.
While she carries the many heavy pieces, she requests DJ to do it, remarking that he is very big and strong, but DJ is too busy worrying about his curse. A concerned Tyler sees Lindsay working alone, and asks her where DJ is, and Lindsay says "Egypt, maybe?" Finally, Lindsay manages to nearly complete the challenge on her own and win another challenge for her team, but DJ comes in on a golf cart while being attacked by Sasquatchanakwa, a bear and a baby seal and destroys all of Lindsay's hard work. Since Lindsay could not remake the entire statue in time, her team loses. This forces a tiebreaker, which DJ believes he will lose. The tiebreaker turns out to be a fashion walk-off, which Lindsay is excited about. She immediately picks Tyler as her model. Lindsay tries out different hairstyles and designs for him, but Tyler approves none of them, wondering what his hockey team back home will think. However, he is glad that she is having fun, but tells her to give him a more dignified outfit.
Her final design for the challenge consists of Tyler wearing a long shirt, made from what seems to be several paintings wrapped together. It is tied with a rope belt and Tyler holding a frame around his face. Her design is disliked by the judges (Chris, Owen and Heather), and Lindsay loses the tiebreaker, disappointing both her and DJ. Lindsay is then sent home, making Tyler upset. However, he cheers up when he realizes that his friends will be able to see his "hot" girlfriend on television, and shows her off to his friends back home. They are unable to kiss, due to Chris saying that they don't have enough time left. Then, Lindsay takes the Drop of Shame. Lindsay jumps off the plane, but hits her head on the door and falls out of the plane, screaming. Her exclusive clip reveals that after the fall, her parachute becomes tangled in a gateway, and leaves her hanging upside down from it. A mime approaches her, and Lindsay asks him whether she can borrow his cellphone. The mime simply imitates her movements in reply, which begins to confuse and annoy her until she eventually begins yelling at him, as she does not realize it is a mime.
Lindsay returns in the aftermath show in Aftermath: Revenge of the Telethon, as the first Aftermath guest that Geoff and Bridgette bring in to raise money. Lindsay's unused lip gloss tubes from Broadway, Baby! are sold to raise money for the show, however Lindsay seems to be unaware of this, wondering if she was supposed to bring presents. She becomes excited when an intern wheels her crate of lip gloss in. Her four hundred remaining tubes of lip gloss are sold for every one hundred dollar donation, in an effort to raise one million dollars due to the Total Drama Jumbo Jet running out of fuel, and being stranded in Jamaica. As soon as Geoff makes this announcement, several calls are made, but it turns out none of them are for Lindsay. Lindsay ends up getting attacked by the animals after the "DJ's World of Animals" segment. As a monkey attacks her, Lindsay calls for Tyler repeatedly, and tries to tell him that someone is stealing her lip gloss.
Lindsay is also one of the five contestants to receive the opportunity to participate in the "Second Chance Challenge" and return to the game in Aftermath Aftermayhem by receiving a "Chris in the box". Lindsay starts off the competition, rolling the dice and landing on the Owen square. Her first challenge is to eat two Jamaican hot peppers and drink milk, while watching funny clips of the show without squirting milk out of her nose. The clips are all of Tyler injuring himself, but Lindsay does not laugh, saying she "never laughs at boyfriends". The hot peppers seem to have no effect on her, but then she then grabs her throat breathes fire from the heat, and Blaineley quickly moves on to the next contestant. Lindsay's second challenge, after landing on the Sweden square, is to balance some of Chef's Swedish meatballs on her nose for at least three seconds. However, she manages to do this before Geoff even tells her what the challenge is, performing it like a sea lion.
Lindsay sits with the rest of the Peanut Gallery in Hawaiian Punch. When Alejandro picks Tyler as one of his helpers, Lindsay sees that Tyler is knocked out from a hit from a golf ball earlier, and volunteers to help Alejandro instead. Lindsay works with Courtney in Versus to construct a dummy of Heather for Alejandro, and ends up winning the challenge, putting Alejandro in the lead. Alejandro takes the lead and tells his team to cut the ropes when he reaches that part of the challenge on the volcano. Heather tells her helpers to block them, which they do. Cody tells the girls that there is a sale on mascara, which causes Lindsay to run away into the depths of the jungle, much to Courtney's exasperation. When Heather defeats Alejandro, Lindsay cheers for her among everyone else.
In Bigger! Badder! Brutal-er!, Lindsay appears on the yacht with the other twenty-three original contestants. She and Tyler are sitting on a rail at the stern of the yacht, making out.
Lindsay returns in Runaway Model as a guest judge for the fashion show, alongside Chris and Chef, and is wearing a new pair of light blue boots. She initially gives the Mutant Maggots a 1.8, but after their maggot vomits and barely misses her (instead hitting Chef), she flips it around to give them an 8.1. Before she can score the Toxic Rats' Sasquatchanakwa, it goes into a fit of rage and kidnaps her, taking her to Boney Island on Chris's jetpack. This results in Chris making the impromptu decision to have the second part of the challenge be saving Lindsay from the Sasquatchanakwa. He takes her to the top of a mountain above a scaffolding that the contestants have to ascend in order to reach them. During her time with him, she seems to understand Sasquatchanakwa and his problems with his body issues. When Jo attempts to save Lindsay from him by putting on makeup (done by "Chester") to distract him, she and Sasquatchanakwa laugh at her. Jo then becomes enraged and punches Sasquatchanakwa off the cliff, "saving" Lindsay. With the challenge over Lindsay checks her makeup, but Jo swipes Lindsay's mirror to check her own face, finally realizing what Lindsay and Sasquatchanakwa found so funny. In a post-elimination scene at the end of the episode, it is revealed that Lindsay was accidentally left behind on Boney Island. She asks the woolly beavers where the boat is, but the beavers growl back and approach her.
In Heroes vs. Villains, Lindsay is one of the contestants brought back to compete in Total Drama All-Stars, and is placed on the Heroic Hamsters. In the season's first challenge, Lindsay is chosen by Courtney to push the baby carriage that transports the team members, as the team had trouble deciding who. However she immediately has trouble remembering how to get to the hotel and also what "pushing" meant, which greatly frustrates Courtney. Lindsay tires out early in the challenge, as Sierra jumps into the carriage with Courtney inside, making it much heavier. Mike is forced to propel the carriage himself with a pole, as Lindsay is too exhausted. Due to her weak performance in the challenge, Lindsay is voted out by her team and is the first all-star eliminated. Lindsay is delighted as she feels the money isn't worth the effort. Her only concern is having to take the Hurl of Shame, but she instead is put through the Flush of Shame. In the exclusive clip of the episode, she ends up in the sewers of New York and encounters the sewer alligator from before. Upon realizing the danger she is in, Lindsay runs away in fear.
In The Final Wreck-ening, Lindsay is seen in one of the balloons. Though she floats away with the others before an intern can get her down.
- View this video for Lindsay's audition tape.
Lindsay mentions all her good traits, stating that the application form asked her to do so. However, she states that she has too many good qualities to state. She begins by saying that she has a bikini for every season (even those not on the calendar), gets along with everyone (even ugly girls), loves to go camping (even though she's never gone) and is self-considered "bi-languagal" (meaning to say bilingual). She says she speaks fluent English and American, being unaware that American isn't a language.
Like many of the campers, Lindsay was featured in the prototype series of Total Drama Island called Camp TV. She was one of the main characters of the show and was originally the main antagonist. Like the current show, Lindsay was portrayed as being a spoiled rich girl, being called "The Spoiled Princess" by the narrator. Lindsay still has a relationship with Tyler, one that seems to be similar to Bridgette and Geoff's in Total Drama Action. Lindsay and Tyler's relationship is the only one portrayed in Camp TV that remained the same in Total Drama Island. Lindsay also seemed to be really close to Leshawna, though with Heather nonexistent in Camp TV and Leshawna offending Lindsay in one scene, it is unknown if they were best friends or adversaries. Lindsay's Camp TV voice is much lower in pitch and sounds more mature and refined compared to her high-pitched and childish tone she has in the Total Drama series. She also recites a line in the Camp TV promo that she would later say in Total Drama Island's second episode: "I thought this was going to be a talent contest!", just before diving off a cliff in both instances. Later in the promo, Harold's red ant farm was seen all over her as she screamed and ran away. This scene was reused in Not Quite Famous, with Heather being the victim instead.
Lindsay's original design is fairly similar to her current design. Outside of the obvious change in art style, Camp TV's Lindsay had a bandanna with white polka dots, sandals instead of boots, a visible reddish-brown thong instead of pink panties, and red tank top straps instead of brown ones. Her hair, while still blonde, was slightly darker and shorter and her chest was flatter.
- Total Drama, Drama, Drama, Drama Island confirms that Lindsay highlights/dyes her hair. She is one out of four contestants to dye her hair in a natural color, the others being Blaineley, Tammy, and Zoey.
- Lindsay, along with Beth, Heather, and Blaineley, is one of the only female contestants from the first generation cast who has not yet appeared on Skatoony.
- Lindsay shares many similarities with third generation cast member Ella:
- Lindsay, along with Alejandro, Brick, Crimson, Duncan, Dwayne, Ennui, Izzy, Jacques, Jay, Josee, Justin, Max, Mickey, most of Mike's personalities, Owen, Rock, Spud, and Sugar are the only contestants to have a theme music dedicated to them. For Lindsay it is a light, fluttery tune which plays whenever she is clueless about something.
- Lindsay, along with Beth, Chris, Duncan, Izzy, and Mike (as Mal), has been arrested by major authorities in the past.
- Lindsay is one of the five characters to stick up her middle finger at someone. The others being Leshawna, Duncan, Sasquatchanakwa, and a beaver.
- She is one of seven original contestants to be a part of a challenge in Total Drama: Revenge of the Island, with the others being Izzy, Gwen, Duncan, Heather, Bridgette and DJ.
- Lindsay is the second eliminated contestant to have a cameo post-elimination, the first being Ezekiel, outside of the recap. This was in Tyler's vision of her in Newf Kids on the Rock.
- Lindsay is the third person to vote for themselves, the others being Gwen, Harold, DJ, and Dave.
- Lindsay is one of only five contestants in Total Drama World Tour to take the Drop of Shame themselves after their elimination, rather than be pushed off by someone else, the others being Harold, DJ, Noah, and Gwen.
- Lindsay is one of three characters in the franchise who wears a bandanna on their head, the others being Miles and Rock.
- Lindsay, along with Courtney, Duncan, Gwen, and Heather, are currently the only five contestants to compete in four seasons.
- Lindsay is the only contestant to compete in four seasons not to reach the final four at any point in the series.
- Lindsay is the only contestant to debut on Total Drama Island to not be on the Vllainous Vultures at any point in Total Drama All-Stars.
- Counting both Total Drama and Total Drama Presents: The Ridonculous Race, Lindsay is one of two contestants in the franchise to have the same ranking twice as she has ranked fourteenth in both Total Drama World Tour and Total Drama All-Stars.
- She is the only contestant to do so twice in the same show.
- Lindsay is also the only member of Team Victory to qualify for Total Drama All-Stars.
- Lindsay is one of the only contestants in the third season to not be eliminated because of Alejandro, with the others being Ezekiel, Gwen, Izzy, and Sierra.
- Lindsay is the only contestant to forget to vote in the competition. This happens in Super Happy Crazy Fun Time Japan.
- Interestingly, while Lindsay placed sixth in Total Drama Action, she was the sixth contestant eliminated in Total Drama World Tour.
- Lindsay is the only member of Heather's original alliance that has never been a finalist of a season.
- Lindsay is never shown without something on her head; she is only seen without her bandanna while in an alternate outfit and even then she wears a hat, sleeping mask or has a towel wrapped around her head. She even wears her bandanna when swimming.
- Lindsay has worn more different outfits than any other contestant on the show:
- Her regular outfit.
- Her yellow bikini and lei, seen in her Total Drama Island promotional picture.
- Her pajamas.
- Her red bikini, seen in Not So Happy Campers - Part 2, Haute Camp-ture, and Beach Blanket Bogus.
- Her shorts and bikini top outfit, slightly different from her regular one, in Up the Creek and briefly in Basic Straining.
- Her green bikini, seen in X-Treme Torture.
- A pink and a different green bikini in her audition tape.
- Her admiral outfit in Full Metal Drama.
- Her pink fur bikini, seen in One Million Bucks, B.C.
- Her Wonder Woman outfit in Super Hero-ld.
- The outfit she wore during her solo in the What's Not To Love musical number in Broadway, Baby!
- She wore blue colored boots in Runaway Model.
- In Celebrity Manhunt's Total Drama Action Reunion Special, Lindsay is seen wearing new red earrings in a triangle shape.
- Despite being clearly unintelligent, there have been several instances where Lindsay has shown some degree of intelligence during the series.
- She is capable of building two fast bicycles (one for Heather and another for herself) in That's Off the Chain!
- In Total Drama, Drama, Drama, Drama Island, Lindsay understands Chris's clue about the location of the briefcase and leads Beth and Ezekiel to the water. Ezekiel even compliments her for this.
- In The Sand Witch Project, she was able to correctly discover Harold and Duncan's plan and was able to keep her team in the game for most of the challenge. However, she completely depended on the "Ghost Meter" and was tricked like the others were when the opposing team managed to activate it. Also, she proposed to her team to choose Beth as the killer as Beth couldn't scream.
- In Get a Clue, she was able to solve the whole mystery about the supposed "death" of Chris, even though she had committed several mistakes during the episode. In the end, after winning her prize, she states that she had made a "good, strategistical, logical move," by inviting Duncan to the movies. This was because, in her opinion, it messed with Courtney's head (in which it did).
- In Can't Help Falling in Louvre, she was able to build the statue of "The Thinker" all by herself, until DJ destroyed it.
- Lindsay is the first contestant in Total Drama Action to use the confessional.
- Lindsay is shown to have a problem with remembering names, as evident throughout the series.
- Assuming the numbers on her mugshot in Celebrity Manhunt's Total Drama Action Reunion Special are shown in feet, Lindsay is about five feet six inches tall, possibly including the heels on her boots.
- Lindsay reveals in Ocean's Eight - Or Nine that she remained in her eighth grade for three years.
|Interactions with||Everyone | Beth | Courtney | Gwen | Heather | Leshawna | Trent | Tyler|
|Eliminated from Total Drama Island|
|Bridgette||That's Off the Chain!||DJ|
|Eliminated from Total Drama Action|
|Justin||Rock n' Rule||Harold|
|Eliminated from Total Drama World Tour|
|Leshawna||Can't Help Falling In Louvre||Izzy|
|Eliminated from Total Drama All-Stars|
|N/A||Heroes vs. Villains||Lightning|
|Screaming Gophers teammates|
|Beth | Cody | Gwen | Heather | Izzy | Justin | Katie | Leshawna | Lindsay | Noah | Owen | Trent|
|Killer Grips teammates|
|Beth | Courtney | Izzy | Justin | Lindsay | Owen | Trent|
|Team Victory teammates|
|Bridgette | DJ | Ezekiel | Harold | Leshawna | Lindsay|
|Heroic Hamsters teammates|
|Cameron | Courtney | Duncan | Lindsay | Mike | Sam | Sierra | Zoey|