Courtney and Lindsay barely interact in Total Drama Island because they are on different teams, and Courtney does not make it to the merge alongside Lindsay. However, Lindsay seems to dislike Courtney's bossy personality in Haute Camp-ture.
The conflict between Courtney and Lindsay dramatically escalates in the Total Drama Action. After Courtney returns to the competition in Ocean's Eight - Or Nine as the result of a lawsuit, she is placed on the Killer Grips, where she immediately clashes with her teammates, including Lindsay. Lindsay is especially unhappy with Courtney's return, since she knows that Courtney will immediately assert herself as the de facto leader of the Grips, meaning that Lindsay would never be taken seriously as a potential leader again. Courtney, on the other hand, becomes frustrated and perplexed that someone as dim-witted as Lindsay is still around in the competition and still popular among her teammates.
Their conflict continues when the teams merge, with Courtney constantly being annoyed by Lindsay's vacuous personality and how she gets by on her looks. Lindsay eventually grows tired of Courtney always taking advantage of her, playing mind games on her in Get a Clue by taking Duncan to the movies with her in order to make Courtney jealous. Additionally, Lindsay attempts to make Courtney mad by teaming up with other contestants to vote off Duncan. Courtney ends up victorious in Rock n' Rule, defeating Lindsay in the challenge and voting her off that night.
Their interactions die down in Total Drama World Tour and Total Drama All-Stars, due to their separate team placements in the former season and Lindsay's early eliminations in both seasons. Regardless, there is still clear tension between them.
When Lindsay sees Courtney beating up Harold with a lamppost, she remarks how she's glad Courtney isn't her C.I.T. After Courtney hits Ezekiel with the same lamppost in retaliation to his comment that she needed to stop complaining of her unfair elimination, Lindsay states that even if Harold hadn't tampered with the votes, Courtney probably would've been voted off eventually since none of the other campers really like her that much. This genuinely shocks Courtney, as she assumed that everyone liked her. Lindsay, along with most of the other former contestants, teases Courtney about her obvious crush on Duncan.
Courtney is frustrated by her team's absence throughout the kart-racing challenge, unknowing of their problems caused by Owen's mental state. She calls Lindsay (along with the rest of the Killer Grips) a "complete dud" and a "slacker" because of this. At the Gilded Chris Awards Ceremony, Courtney is technically voted off by Lindsay and the other Grips. This proves to be to no avail, as Courtney had immunity for this episode due to the settlement of her lawsuit. Lindsay was shown to be upset at Courtney's decision to vote off Owen afterward.
Lindsay calls Courtney "Bossy McSmartypants" and a "know-it-all," and is shown to be very disappointed with her return. She, along with Beth, gives Courtney a glare when Courtney walks into the girls' trailer. After Chris reveals the unfair advantages Courtney would receive due to her lawsuit, Lindsay is shown to be angry about it, especially after Chris revealed that Courtney would have her own private bathroom. Later, Lindsay is shown to be clueless about how to start a fire with the flint rocks she was given. Courtney grows annoyed at this, forcefully grabbing the rocks from Lindsay. Lindsay is shown in the confessional immediately afterward, frowning and complaining about how bossy Courtney is. Shortly after, when Courtney fails miserably to start a fire, Lindsay obliviously picks up the two rocks once again and, by clacking them together briefly and lightly, she inexplicably causes a massive fire to burst into their fire pit.
Courtney tones down her hostility towards Lindsay, being more cooperative with her team. They cheer for each other during their individual challenges. Towards the end, Courtney states that the contestants, including Lindsay, have the right to know the terrible things Leshawna said about them behind their backs.
Later, after Chris rewards Courtney and Lindsay with a trip to a cheese factory for solving the challenges in the episode, Courtney is dismayed at having to go with Lindsay. She outright tells Lindsay that she does not like her at all, though Lindsay does not seem to mind at all. In the episode's exclusive clip, while Lindsay appears to be enjoying their trip to the cheese factory, Courtney doesn't and glares at Lindsay when she hugs her by the neck. When Lindsay suggests they play a game of "Think Of All the Cheeses They Can," Courtney finally snaps at Lindsay and jumps out of the Lame-o-sine while it's still moving.
In the recap for the previous episode, it shows that Courtney and Lindsay ended up having to take the trip to the cheese factory together after all. Lindsay hugs Courtney in her excitement, clearly angering Courtney. At the beginning of the episode, the two are shown criticizing one another because of their bad stench caused by the cheeses. After Chris explains the challenge for the day, Courtney smirks and derisively remarks that Lindsay could call herself "Gorgonzola Girl" and use her stench as her superpower, prompting Leshawna to stand up for Lindsay and retorting that Courtney could be "Aged Cheddar Chick."
As the contestants gather materials for their superhero costumes, Courtney and Lindsay fight for a piece of fabric which Courtney ends up taking after shoving Lindsay to the ground. Lindsay is shown in a confessional complaining about Courtney's "super power trip" because of this. When Lindsay dresses up as Wonder Woman as her superhero, Courtney criticizes Lindsay for her lack of originality, reminding her that Wonder Woman already exists. Despite that, Lindsay ends up winning since Chris was a fan of the original Wonder Woman.
Lindsay later becomes upset at Courtney for stepping on her invisible jet. All of the remaining men side with her, angering Courtney. As Lindsay was failing the obstacle course challenge, Courtney bitterly teases her by saying that she is "not such a Wonder Woman now." After Courtney wins invincibility, Lindsay is shown in the communal bathroom to be disappointed that they can't vote off Courtney. Instead, she agrees with Beth's idea of voting Duncan off, hoping it will infuriate Courtney.
The conflict between the two reaches its peak in this episode. At this point, Lindsay is completely fed up with Courtney's attitude and resolves to prove that she can outsmart Courtney, although it's initially to little avail. As for Courtney, she becomes angry that the others even listen to the ideas of the "dingbat" in the first place. When the contestants are trying to figure where Chris is at the beginning of the episode, Lindsay suggests that he is buried alive under the craft services tent, and encourages the others to start digging. Courtney is later shown belittling this idea after they find Chris, which leads to Lindsay replying that Courtney is "not nice."
After Beth intervenes, Courtney seemingly does a U-turn, apologizing to Lindsay, and stating that she was only acting antagonistic to Lindsay out of "jealousy" over Lindsay's intelligence. She then treats Lindsay to a manicure, which Lindsay happily complies to. This turns out to be a trick to get Lindsay's fingerprints and DNA, which were needed for the next part of the challenge. A short time later, Lindsay tries to get Courtney's prints in retaliation by laying down paint and a piece of paper on the ground of the communal bathroom so she can get Courtney's footprint once she steps out of the shower. However, this fails due to the water smearing the footprint. Courtney is then shown condescendingly patting Lindsay on the back in a mock show of sympathy.
When the contestants are charged with solving Chris's "murderer" on the train, Lindsay initially suggests that they give Chris's "corpse" fruit juice to revive him. Courtney categorically dismisses this as a lousy idea. The two of them have a different approach to the challenge, with Lindsay trying to figure out who the killer is while Courtney instead tries to find a way to get out of the train while insisting the challenge is all a set-up. It is later revealed in a confessional after Lindsay says that she could be "just as right about the challenge as Courtney is," that, even though Courtney wasn't completely sure if the challenge was fake or not, she didn't want Lindsay to know as Courtney wanted to be the leader.
In the end, Lindsay is able to determine through a clever analysis of Courtney's fingerprints and an unflattering sketch of Courtney devouring her cheese puffs earlier in the episode that Courtney is the killer, as she had been set up by Chris to look like the culprit. She orders the others to handcuff Courtney, but before that can happen, the real Chris suddenly enters and announces Lindsay as the winner of the challenge. Courtney is incredulous and indignant after hearing that Lindsay won, arguing that she deserved the win more than her. When Lindsay wins the prize—a night at the movies with a friend of her choice)—she takes Duncan instead of Beth, to successfully make Courtney jealous. Lindsay is then shown in a confessional to have thoroughly enjoyed her revenge, even though she didn't have a good time with Duncan.
Courtney becomes completely annoyed by Lindsay's off-key singing and singing the incorrect lyrics at the beginning of the episode. She also accuses Lindsay of taking Duncan to the movies as "retaliation" against her. Later on, Courtney is also upset that Lindsay won the red carpet challenge instead of her because she posed and greeted rather than trying to avoid them. In the confessional afterward, she even calls Lindsay by the derogatory name Heather coined for her, "Lindsiot." In the final part of the challenge, trashing a mock hotel room), Courtney goes berserk and completely destroy the room. As she does so, she almost throws a bed with a terrified Lindsay on it before Chris intervenes. Lindsay tries to convince Beth, Owen, and Harold to eliminated Duncan because "[Courtney would] go ballistic if he got kicked off!" At the Gilded Chris ceremony that night, Courtney gladly votes for Lindsay. Moments later, it is revealed that Lindsay accidentally eliminated herself by voting for herself while she was distracted by Beth.
Even though Courtney voted for her, Courtney calls Lindsay "selfish" and "thoughtless" in the confessional for leaving the girls outnumbered and forcing her to form an alliance with Beth.
In order to get back at Duncan for cheating on her, Courtney begins to flirt with Lindsay's boyfriend, Tyler, despite knowing that he is already in a relationship with Lindsay.Heather. They are also both seen trying to set off the booby traps to slow down Heather and allow Alejandro to gain the lead. After Cody tricks Lindsay into thinking there is a sale on mascara, Courtney becomes annoyed when Lindsay thinks Cody is telling the truth, particularly considering they are in the middle of the jungle on an active volcano where there is no mall.
As they are walking to the first challenge, Lindsay gives Courtney advice in regards to Duncan, and Courtney replies she isn't going to make that mistake again. However, Lindsay misinterprets this as Courtney discovering how to never make mistakes at all and asks Courtney to teach her how to do so.
When the Heroic Hamsters have trouble deciding who should push the stroller, Courtney immediately chooses Lindsay. However, to Courtney's frustration, Lindsay has somehow forgotten how and where to push the stroller to. In the end, Courtney votes Lindsay off for her poor performance, while Lindsay presumably attempted to vote Courtney off but drew an X over her own face instead.
- This conflict is closely related to the conflict between Beth and Courtney and the friendship between Beth and Lindsay.
- Both have been the first contestants to use the confessional booth in a season:
- Both have/had a relationship with a former member of the Killer Bass.
- Both are the only contestants to compete in four seasons to not reach the final two at any point in the series.
- Both have placed fourteenth in a season, with Courtney doing so in Total Drama Island and Lindsay doing so in two seasons.
|Interactions with||Everyone | Alejandro | Beth | Bridgette | Chris | Duncan | Gwen | Harold | Heather | Lindsay | Scott|
|Other content||Courtney's alliances | Courtney's lawyers | Courtney's personal digital assistant|
|Interactions with||Everyone | Beth | Courtney | Gwen | Heather | Leshawna | Trent | Tyler|